Apple Disputes French Findings, Says iPhone 12 Meets Radiation Rules
Apple Responds to French Watchdog’s Order
On Wednesday, Apple issued a statement in response to the order from the French radiation watchdog, ANFR, to stop selling iPhone 12 models in France. The watchdog claimed that tests showed that the Specific Absorption Rate (SAR) of the iPhone 12 exceeded the legally allowed limit set by European exposure standards. However, Apple maintained that the iPhone 12 complies with all global radiation standards and has been certified by multiple international bodies.
The ANFR’s Allegations
The ANFR claimed that during its tests, the iPhone 12 showed an SAR of 5.74 watts per kilogram, which exceeded the European standard of 4.0 watts per kilogram when the phone was held in the hand or kept in a trouser pocket. However, it also noted that the phone complied with body-SAR standards when it was placed in a jacket pocket or bag. The ANFR stated that it expects Apple to take immediate action to rectify the non-compliance, and warned that a failure to do so would result in a recall of iPhone 12s already sold to consumers.
Apple‘s Response
Apple responded to these allegations by stating that it had provided ANFR with multiple lab results from both Apple and independent third-party labs, which proved the iPhone 12’s compliance with SAR regulations and standards worldwide. The company contested the results of ANFR’s review and expressed its intent to continue engaging with the agency to demonstrate its compliance.
French Minister Calls for Software Update
The junior minister for the digital economy in France, Jean-Noel Barrot, suggested that a software update would be sufficient to address the radiation issues associated with the iPhone 12. In an interview with Le Parisien, Barrot stated that Apple has two weeks to respond, and if the company fails to do so, he is prepared to order a recall of all iPhone 12s in circulation. He emphasized that the rules apply to everyone, including digital giants like Apple.
Potential Implications and Next Steps
The recall of iPhone 12s in France could have significant consequences for Apple, given that Europe is its second-largest market behind the Americas. However, Apple has not publicly disclosed its sales figures by country or model. The ANFR will share its findings with regulators in other European Union member states, which could potentially lead to broader actions against Apple in the region.
The Impact of SAR Values on Health
The European Union has set safety limits for SAR values linked to exposure to mobile phones, citing scientific studies that suggest an increased risk of certain forms of cancer. As such, the ANFR’s findings raise concerns about the potential health risks associated with the iPhone 12. If Apple is found to be non-compliant with European radiation regulations, it may face further scrutiny and potentially legal consequences.
France’s Regulations on Radiation Disclosure
This latest development follows France’s decision in 2020 to expand regulations requiring retailers to display the radiation value of products on packaging, extending beyond cell phones to include tablets and other electronic devices. The intention behind this requirement is to inform consumers about potential exposure to radiation and give them the ability to make informed choices when purchasing electronic devices.
Editorial and Recommendations
This dispute between Apple and the French watchdog highlights the ongoing concern regarding the health effects of radiation emitted by mobile phones. While Apple claims its iPhone 12 complies with global radiation standards, the ANFR’s tests suggest otherwise. This raises important questions about the adequacy of current global standards and the need for further research to better understand the potential risks associated with prolonged exposure to mobile phone radiation.
In light of these concerns, it is crucial for both consumers and regulatory authorities to be vigilant about the potential health risks of mobile phone use. The ANFR’s emphasis on transparency and regulation is commendable, as it prioritizes consumer safety over corporate interests.
In the short term, it is essential for Apple to address the allegations and engage with the ANFR to resolve the issue. This should include providing additional evidence or implementing any necessary updates to ensure compliance with European radiation regulations. By doing so, Apple can demonstrate its commitment to consumer safety and regain the trust of both French regulators and its customers.
Long-term solutions should involve a comprehensive review of radiation regulations and standards worldwide, with a focus on strengthening consumer protections and promoting accurate and accessible information about the potential risks associated with mobile phone radiation. This would enable individuals to make informed decisions about their device usage and encourage manufacturers to prioritize the development of safer technologies.
Ultimately, it is incumbent upon governments, regulatory bodies, and technology companies like Apple to work together to ensure that mobile phones and other electronic devices meet stringent safety standards. By prioritizing the health and well-being of consumers, we can strike a balance between technological innovation and safeguarding public health.
<< photo by MART PRODUCTION >>
The image is for illustrative purposes only and does not depict the actual situation.
