Ex-Man City star Benjamin Mendy cleared of rape charges

Ex-Man City footballer Benjamin Mendy found not guilty of rape

Published 11 hours ago

Share close panel Share page Copy link About sharing

Accusations and Defence

During the trial, prosecutor Benjamin Aina KC claimed that Mendy took advantage of female guests at parties held in his home. Aina alleged that Mendy’s wealth and celebrity status created an environment where he was not accustomed to being denied.

The first complainant, referred to as woman A, testified that she first met Mendy in a nightclub in Barcelona in late 2017 and became intimate with one of his friends. Approximately a year later, she visited Mendy’s house to meet up with his friend after a night out with other girls. Woman A alleged that the following morning, while she was taking a shower in the en-suite bathroom, Mendy appeared uninvited, wearing only boxer shorts. She claimed that Mendy then forcibly grabbed her and attempted to rape her on the bed, despite her repeated objections. Mendy countered this by stating that they were “flirting” during the night out and that when he went to her room the next morning, they began embracing on a bed. He added that when he informed her he had already obtained his friend’s approval, she became upset. Mendy denied attempting to rape her.

The second complainant, referred to as woman B, testified that she and her friends were invited back to Mendy’s house in 2019 after a night out at a bar near his home in Alderley Edge, Cheshire. The 24-year-old alleged that Mendy took her phone, which contained “intimate” photos, and led her to his locked bedroom while she requested her phone back. She stated that Mendy told her, “I just wanna have a look at you” and asked her to undress, which she did. Woman B stated that Mendy then threw her phone on the bed and proceeded to rape her despite her refusal to engage in sexual activity. She claimed that Mendy later told her, “You’re too shy. It’s fine. I’ve had sex with 10,000 women.” Mendy disputed this account, asserting that the woman had consented to engage in intimate behavior on the bed and that they subsequently exchanged contact details to connect on Snapchat.

The Trials and Verdict

In the first trial, Mendy was acquitted on multiple counts but faced two charges on which the jury could not reach a verdict. These undecided charges prompted a re-trial, which culminated in his recent acquittal.

After the verdict was announced, Mendy’s solicitor, Jenny Wiltshire, expressed gratitude to the jury for their impartial assessment of the evidence. She emphasized the importance of focusing on the facts rather than engaging with the “rumour and innuendo” that had circulated since the beginning of the case. Wiltshire added that Mendy had experienced significant emotional impact throughout the legal process and requested that his privacy be respected as he seeks to rebuild his life.

Analysis and Commentary

The acquittal of Benjamin Mendy on charges of rape and attempted rape raises significant questions about the handling of sexual assault cases and the role of fame and wealth in the legal system. The jury’s decision not only affects Mendy’s reputation but also has broader implications for survivors of sexual assault.

It is crucial to acknowledge the complexities of sexual assault cases. In this case, there were conflicting accounts from the complainants and the defendant, making it challenging for the jury to reach a unanimous verdict. However, it is essential to ensure that survivors feel supported and that their voices are heard throughout the legal process.

Additionally, the role of power dynamics and privilege cannot be ignored. Mendy’s status as a professional footballer and his wealth may have influenced the dynamics in his relationships with women, creating an environment where consent is blurred and boundaries are disregarded. The court’s decision should prompt conversations about consent, power imbalances, and the responsibility of individuals with influence to ensure the well-being and safety of their partners.

Advice and Moving Forward

The case of Benjamin Mendy highlights the importance of ongoing discussions about consent, respect, and the prevention of sexual assault. It is crucial for individuals and communities to engage in conversations that challenge societal attitudes and behaviors that perpetuate sexual violence.

To survivors of sexual assault, it is essential to remember that there are support systems available to you. Reach out to helplines, counseling services, or organizations that specialize in assisting survivors. Your experiences are valid, and seeking help is a sign of strength.

For society as a whole, this case should serve as a reminder that no one is above the law. Regardless of status or wealth, everyone must be held accountable for their actions. It is imperative to continue advocating for a justice system that prioritizes the needs and well-being of survivors while ensuring a fair and unbiased legal process.

Furthermore, education on consent and healthy relationships should be prioritized, particularly in settings where power imbalances are prevalent. By equipping individuals with the knowledge and understanding of boundaries and consent, we can work towards creating a safer and more respectful society.

Image source: