“Kelly Clarkson Slams Industry Deception over ‘Since U Been Gone’…”

## Entertainment Weekly: Kelly Clarkson Says She Was ‘Lied To’ About ‘Since U Been Gone’ Songwriting: ‘I Looked Like a Fool’

*By Shania Russell, Published on 29 June 2023 at 2:18 am*

Nearly two decades after its release, Kelly Clarkson’s hit song “Since U Been Gone” continues to be a fan-favorite and one of her most ubiquitous hits. However, Clarkson recently revealed that she still carries a negative association with the track due to the deceptive practices surrounding its creation.

During a recent appearance on Watch What Happens Live, Clarkson responded to claims made by media mogul Clive Davis, the former head of RCA Records, who stated that Clarkson didn’t want to release the single. Clarkson contested these claims and stated that she was “lied to” about the song’s origins.

According to Clarkson, she was approached by the label with the opportunity to work with producers Max Martin and Dr. Luke on a song. When she was presented with the song, it was still unfinished and had dummy lyrics. Nonetheless, she was instructed to write her own lyrics for the track.

However, when she arrived in Sweden to work with the producers, Clarkson discovered that they had already written the lyrics to “Since U Been Gone.” This revelation left her feeling foolish and betrayed, as the label had misled her about the songwriting process.

“Why lie to me like that?,” Clarkson questioned. “That’s a red flag.” The experience left her with a “bad vibe” surrounding the song and its origin story.

Despite the negative association with the track, Clarkson shared that she is able to compartmentalize her feelings and deliver a powerful performance when singing “Since U Been Gone” onstage. She described herself as a “great compartmentalizer” who can put aside personal feelings to give her all during performances.

This revelation from Clarkson comes in the context of her complicated relationship with Clive Davis. In Davis’ memoir, “The Soundtrack of My Life,” he shared various stories about Clarkson, including anecdotes she has since disputed, such as her allegedly weeping during a meeting and her disinterest in releasing future hit songs like “Since U Been Gone” and “Behind These Hazel Eyes.” In an open letter to her fans, Clarkson firmly stated that these stories were “not true at all” and accused Davis of mixing up his stories and songs.

This latest controversy surrounding “Since U Been Gone” sheds light on some of the behind-the-scenes practices in the music industry. Deceptive tactics and lack of transparency in the creative process can result in misunderstandings and strained relationships between artists and label executives.

## Editorial: The Ethical Dilemma of Deception in the Music Industry

Deception and dishonesty have long plagued the music industry, with stories of artists being taken advantage of by record labels and industry executives. The case of Kelly Clarkson and the deceptive practices surrounding the creation of “Since U Been Gone” highlights the need for greater transparency and ethical conduct in the music industry.

Artists put their trust in labels and producers to guide them through the creative process and promote their work. When that trust is violated, as in the case of Clarkson, it can lead to feelings of betrayal and a tarnished perception of a once-beloved song.

The story of “Since U Been Gone” serves as a cautionary tale for aspiring artists and industry professionals. It emphasizes the importance of open and honest communication, not just between artists and labels, but also within the entire creative team. Clear expectations and transparent practices can help prevent misunderstandings and foster healthier working relationships.

Furthermore, this incident raises questions about the power dynamics within the music industry. Artists often find themselves in vulnerable positions, relying on executives and producers to navigate their careers. It is crucial for industry professionals to prioritize the well-being and creative autonomy of artists, rather than prioritizing commercial success at any cost. True collaboration and respect for artistic vision are essential for a healthier and more ethical music industry.

## Advice for Artists: Navigating Deceptive Practices

For artists finding themselves in the midst of deceptive practices or situations similar to Clarkson’s, it is important to remember that you have a voice and the right to speak up for yourself. Here are a few suggestions for navigating such situations:

1. **Seek Legal Advice**: If you suspect that you have been misled or deceived, consult with a lawyer who specializes in entertainment law. They can help you understand your rights and guide you through the legal process.

2. **Document Everything**: Keep a record of all communication and agreements throughout the creative process. Written evidence can be valuable if disputes arise.

3. **Communicate Openly**: Establish clear lines of communication with your team and label representatives. Ask questions, express concerns, and ensure that expectations are understood by all parties involved.

4. **Collaborate with Trusted Professionals**: Surround yourself with professionals who have a proven track record of ethical conduct and respect for artists’ creative vision. Build a support system that prioritizes your well-being.

5. **Educate Yourself**: Stay informed about industry practices, contracts, and rights as an artist. The more knowledge you have, the better equipped you will be to navigate complex situations.

6. **Trust Your Instincts**: If something feels off or too good to be true, trust your instincts. Take the time to evaluate the situation and seek advice from trusted professionals.

## In Conclusion

Kelly Clarkson’s revelation about the deceptive practices surrounding the creation of “Since U Been Gone” raises important questions about transparency, trust, and ethical conduct in the music industry. It serves as a reminder that artists deserve respect, honesty, and fairness throughout the creative process. By prioritizing open communication and collaboration, industry professionals can contribute to a healthier and more ethically sound music industry. Aspiring artists should be aware of their rights, seek trusted advice, and trust their instincts when navigating potentially deceptive situations.

Music-kellyclarkson,industrydeception,sinceubeengone