“The Fungus Enigma: The Dangers of Can’t Tell the Difference while Foraging for Wild Mushrooms”

‘Can’t tell the difference’: Why foraging for wild mushrooms can end in painful death

By

August 8, 2023

Australian food safety expert Lydia Buchtmann has issued a stern warning against foraging for wild mushrooms, comparing it to a game of Russian roulette. Buchtmann, spokesperson for the Food Safety Information Council, expressed concern over the recent deaths of three individuals who unknowingly consumed highly toxic death cap or yellow-staining mushrooms. The victims attended a lunch party in Victoria, where the deadly mushrooms were mistakenly included in the meal.

Buchtmann explained that distinguishing between a death cap mushroom and a safe mushroom poses a significant challenge, even for mushroom experts. The appearance of these mushrooms varies at different stages of growth, making identification unreliable. The death cap mushroom, which closely resembles common edible mushrooms sold in supermarkets, is lethal even in small amounts. Consuming as little as a teaspoon can be fatal, with no known cure.

Death caps are widely regarded as the most poisonous mushrooms worldwide. Just one death cap is enough to kill an adult human. In Victoria, where the tragic lunch party took place, death caps are often found near oak trees in warm, wet weather.

Previous incidents and risks

This is not the first time mushroom poisoning has made headlines in Australia. In 2012, two individuals died after consuming poisonous mushrooms at a New Year’s Eve dinner party in Canberra. The meal was prepared by a trained culinary chef who had mistakenly misidentified the species.

Death cap mushrooms are not native to Australia but are believed to have spread through the shipping of timber and live seedlings from Europe. Buchtmann cautioned individuals born overseas, particularly in Asia, to be cautious as death caps can mimic edible mushrooms commonly gathered in their home countries. The mushroom has been observed not just in Victoria, but also in Tasmania, Adelaide, and the Australian Capital Territory.

Symptoms and long-term effects

Symptoms of mushroom poisoning typically appear between 10 and 16 hours after consumption and include vomiting, diarrhea, and stomach cramps. While the symptoms may initially subside, a terminal phase of three to four days often follows. Without immediate medical intervention, victims may slip into a coma, experiencing liver and kidney failure for two to three weeks.

Aside from death caps, other wild mushrooms in Australia can also cause serious illness, including the Cortinarius and Galerina species, the ghost mushroom, and the yellow-stainer, often mistaken for field mushrooms. The yellow-stainer is the most commonly ingested poisonous mushroom in Victoria and New South Wales.

Expert advice and precautions

Buchtmann’s advice is clear: avoid picking or consuming wild mushrooms altogether. The risk of misidentification and the potentially fatal consequences make foraging for wild mushrooms too dangerous. Mushroom gathering should be left to experts with the necessary knowledge and skills to distinguish between toxic and non-toxic varieties.

If someone suspects they have ingested a poisonous mushroom, immediate action is vital. They should seek medical attention at a hospital emergency department. If possible, the mushroom should be taken along for identification purposes. In addition, the Poisons Information Centre can be contacted nationwide on 13 11 26.

Investigation and legal implications

As authorities in Victoria continue to investigate the recent mushroom poisoning incidents, it remains unclear whether the poisoning resulted from a deliberate act or a tragic accident. The outcome of the investigation may have legal implications, depending on the circumstances surrounding the inclusion of the deadly mushrooms in the meal.

The incidents serve as a stark reminder of the dangers that can lurk in nature, even in seemingly harmless activities such as foraging for mushrooms. It underscores the importance of education, awareness, and exercising caution when engaging in any form of wild food gathering.

Contact the author: edward.felsenthal@gmail.com