AFL Finals: GWS coach Adam Kingsley slams last quarter HIA decision

AFL Finals: GWS coach Adam Kingsley criticises HIA decision in the last quarter

By

Published on September 23, 2023

GWS Giants coach Adam Kingsley has expressed his dissatisfaction with the decision to remove Brent Daniels from the preliminary final due to a concussion test. The incident occurred during a tackle by Collingwood star Nick Daicos, where Daniels’ head was driven into the ground. While Daicos is unlikely to face suspension, the tackle will be scrutinized by the Match Review Officer.

The tackle on Daniels came from behind into his back, rather than a slinging motion. Although Daniels remained on the field for an additional seven minutes before being taken off following a goal by Jesse Hogan, Kingsley believes that the tackle did not warrant his removal for an assessment. Kingsley plans to seek clarification from the AFL regarding the incident.

Implications for Player Safety

The issue of player safety has always been a significant concern in the AFL. With the growing awareness of the long-term effects of head injuries, strict protocols for concussion management have been implemented to protect players from potentially serious consequences.

It is crucial that the AFL continues to prioritize the well-being of its players by consistently enforcing these protocols and ensuring fair adjudication in cases where player safety is at risk.

Importance of Independent Medical Assessments

The decision to remove a player for a head impact assessment (HIA) is overseen by an independent AFL doctor, separate from the club’s medical team. This independent assessment is vital in maintaining the integrity of the process and ensuring unbiased decisions that prioritize player safety.

The Role of Coaches

Adam Kingsley’s criticism highlights the challenges that coaches face in balancing their concern for player welfare and their desire for on-field success. While it is understandable that Kingsley was disappointed to lose a valuable player during a crucial stage of the game, it is essential for coaches to trust the professional judgment of the independent medical experts involved.

Coaches must maintain a long-term perspective and prioritize the health and safety of their players over short-term tactical advantages. This requires a delicate balance between their responsibilities as leaders and their desire to win matches.

Player Leadership and Team Culture

Kingsley praised GWS captain Toby Greene for his care and support of his teammates following the heartbreaking one-point loss. The role of a captain extends beyond on-field performance, and Greene’s ability to uplift and motivate his teammates is a testament to his leadership skills.

A strong team culture that fosters support, resilience, and camaraderie is essential for success in professional sports. The example set by captains like Greene can have a profound impact on team dynamics and contribute to the growth and development of players.

The Future of GWS Giants

Despite the disappointment of narrowly missing out on a Grand Final berth, Kingsley expressed confidence in the talent and potential of the GWS Giants. The team has secured the signatures of promising players such as Harry Himmelberg, Jake Riccardi, and Lachie Ash, while former captain Callan Ward will continue to play in 2024.

Kingsley believes that the Giants already possess the necessary tools for continued success, but acknowledges the possibility of making strategic upgrades in certain areas. As they reflect on their first season under Kingsley’s leadership, the Giants can take pride in the vibrant and attractive playing style they have embraced.

Conclusion

The criticism raised by Adam Kingsley regarding the HIA decision in the last quarter of the preliminary final sheds light on the ongoing challenges faced by the AFL in ensuring player safety. It is crucial for the league to maintain strict protocols and independent medical assessments to protect the well-being of its players.

Coaches, while passionate about their team’s success, must prioritize the health and safety of their players and trust the judgments made by independent medical experts. A strong team culture and the leadership of players like Toby Greene are essential components for building a successful and resilient team.

The GWS Giants, despite the disappointment of this season, are well-positioned for future success with a talented roster and the potential for strategic improvements. As they move forward, they must continue to embrace their vibrant playing style and build on the positives of their first season under Kingsley’s guidance.